_edited.jpg)
Why You Feel Broke on a Good Income (And What To Do About It)
- May 3
- 4 min read
I hear this a lot.
Someone’s on a solid income. Sometimes very solid. Yet they feel like they’re treading water. Payday comes, bills go out, and there’s this quiet anxiety sitting in the background. If that’s you, I want to say this clearly.
You’re not bad with money. You’re just playing a game you didn’t design. Most people think this problem is “I need a better budget”. Sometimes a budget helps, sure. But often the real issue is more human than that. It’s lifestyle creep, mixed with identity, and a bunch of invisible expectations that no one ever sat down and agreed to.
The trap: more income, same feeling
When your income goes up, the story in your head changes. You’re doing well now. You should be able to breathe. You should be able to enjoy things. You should be able to keep up. So you upgrade, a little at a time.
A slightly better place. A car that feels safer or more reliable. Better holidays. More eating out. A few subscriptions. Nicer groceries. School costs. Private health. Activities for the kids. Convenience spending because you’re tired and busy. None of those choices are “wrong”. Most of them make sense in isolation. The issue is what happens when they stack on top of each other. Your income grows, but so do your commitments. And oddly, life satisfaction does not rise at the same pace. That gap is where the “I feel broke” feeling lives.
Fixed costs quietly take over
Here’s a simple way to think about it.
There are fixed costs, and there is flexible joy. Fixed costs are the things that lock in. Housing, car repayments, childcare, insurance, debt, ongoing commitments. Once they’re in, they’re hard to unwind. Even if you want to. Flexible joy is the spending that actually gives you a lift. A weekend away. Seeing friends. Taking the kids somewhere fun. A hobby. A good meal out that you really enjoy, not just because it’s Thursday and you cannot be bothered cooking.
The problem is not that you spend money on yourself. The problem is when your flexible joy gets squeezed out by fixed costs. That’s when you can be on a great income and still feel trapped. Because being “broke” is not just about the numbers. It’s about having no room to move.
Invisible expectations are expensive
There’s another layer that people do not talk about much.
Identity. At some point, your spending stops being about what you need, and starts being about who you are. The professional version of you. The parent version of you. The successful version of you. The person who has “made it”. Then there are the expectations you did not choose, but you feel anyway. What people like us do. What people at work do. What people in our suburb do. What your friends seem to do. What social media quietly tells you is normal.
That pressure is often invisible, but it is real. And it can cost a fortune.
What to do about it (without turning your life into a spreadsheet)
Here are a few practical steps that will actually work.
Do a quick “money reality check”.
Not a perfect budget. Just look at the last month or two and sort spending into three buckets: fixed costs, flexible joy, and defaults. Defaults are the things you pay for because it is routine, convenient, or you have not questioned it in ages.
Pick one fixed cost to challenge.
Not everything. Just one. This could be a car upgrade cycle, a subscription bundle, a high ongoing service, or a housing decision you made in a different season of life. You are not trying to punish yourself. You are trying to buy back breathing room.
Protect flexible joy on purpose.
If you cut spending, but you only cut the things that make life feel good, you will rebound. That is normal. Decide what genuinely matters and keep it. Cut the things that do not add much, even if they look good on paper.
Make a rule for your next pay rise or bonus.
This is where people win the game. Decide in advance how it will be split. Some goes to the future you, some goes to enjoying life now, and some can go to lifestyle upgrades if you truly want them. The key is that you choose, not your spending habits.
Define what “enough” looks like for you.
Not forever. Just for this stage of life. When you know what enough is, you stop chasing a moving target.
If you feel broke on a good income, it is usually not because you are irresponsible. It is because your life got more expensive in ways that felt normal at the time. The good news is that you can redesign the game. You do not need a new personality. You need a bit more clarity, and a bit more margin. And if you want help working out what to change first, that’s the sort of conversation I have with clients every day.
Go well…
Ben G-N
Stay in touch with all of our content. Click here to subscribe.
Ben Graham-Nellor is an advisor, coach, blogger and speaker who has worked in the financial services industry for over 15 years. He believes that by educating and advising people today, they can improve their tomorrow.
Ben Graham-Nellor is a Sub Authorised Representative (291391) of BGN Financial Management PTY LTD (ABN 45 672 104 196) which is a corporate authorised representative (468796) of Professional Investment Services Pty Ltd (ABN 11 074 608 558) which is the holder of Australian Financial Services License No.234951. Website |www.centrepointalliance.com.au/PIS
BGN Financial Management PTY LTD is corporate credit representative No 528966 of Centrepoint Alliance Lending ABN 40 100 947 804 (Australian Credit Licence Number 377711)
Smart Happy Money is a trading name of BGN Financial Management PTY LTD
This information has been provided as general advice. We have not considered your financial circumstances, needs or objectives. You should consider the appropriateness of the advice. You should obtain and consider the relevant Product Disclosure Statement (PDS) and seek the assistance of an authorised financial adviser before making any decision regarding any products or strategies mentioned in this communication.
